Warranty Claim Expert
Colleagues reviewing printed charts and financial reports on a table beside a laptop and tablet

·11 min read

Accounting Warranty Claims: How Experts Assess Whether Financial Statements Match the Agreed Accounting Basis

How an expert compares warranted financial statements with the accounting basis an SPA specifies: policies, consistency, supporting records and the financial effect of any difference.

Financial statement warranties can form an important part of a share purchase agreement. They may address matters such as the preparation of accounts, applicable accounting standards, consistency of accounting policies and the financial position of the target company.

When an accounting warranty claim arises, an issue might be whether the financial statements were prepared in accordance with the accounting basis specified by the transaction documents. That assessment may require examination of the relevant accounts, accounting policies, supporting records and the wording of the SPA.

The agreed accounting basis can be particularly important. The relevant question is not necessarily limited to whether the accounts comply with accounting standards in isolation. The contractual wording, stated accounting policies and other provisions of the SPA may also need to be considered.

What Is an Accounting Warranty?

An accounting warranty is a contractual statement concerning the financial statements or accounting records of a target business.

The precise wording varies between transactions. Depending on the SPA, an accounting warranty may address matters such as:

  • Whether the accounts give a true and fair view
  • Whether the accounts comply with applicable accounting standards
  • Whether accounting policies have been applied consistently
  • Whether accounting records have been properly maintained
  • Whether particular liabilities or financial matters have been disclosed
  • Whether the accounts were prepared using specified accounting policies

The wording of the individual warranty is important because it determines the particular issue that may need to be examined.

An accounting warranty should therefore be considered in the context of the SPA as a whole rather than in isolation.

For information about the wider role of a warranty claim expert, see What Is a Warranty Claim Expert?.

What Is the Agreed Accounting Basis?

The agreed accounting basis is the accounting framework specified by the SPA for a particular set of financial calculations or accounts.

It may refer to:

  • The accounting policies of the target company
  • Policies applied in specified reference accounts
  • Applicable accounting standards
  • Specific accounting principles set out in the SPA
  • Definitions or calculation provisions agreed between the parties

The exact basis depends on the transaction documents.

For example, an SPA may require financial information to be prepared using the target company's accounting policies as applied in its reference accounts. In another transaction, additional contractual provisions may specify how particular items should be treated.

Determining whether financial statements match the agreed accounting basis may therefore require examination of both the applicable accounting requirements and the contractual wording.

For further information on accounting standards analysis, see Accounting Standards Opinion.

Why Does the Agreed Accounting Basis Matter?

Accounting standards provide a framework for financial reporting, but an SPA may contain additional requirements concerning how financial information is to be prepared or interpreted.

A dispute may therefore arise even where the parties agree on the general accounting framework but disagree about how a particular provision applies to the transaction.

The relevant questions may include:

  1. What accounting basis does the SPA specify?
  2. Which accounting policies apply?
  3. Were those policies applied consistently?
  4. Are there transaction-specific provisions affecting the treatment?
  5. What treatment was actually adopted?
  6. What treatment does the agreed basis require?
  7. Does any difference affect the financial position relevant to the warranty?

These questions require consideration of the wording and evidence applicable to the particular transaction.

How an Expert May Review Financial Statements

The precise scope of an expert's work depends on the instructions and issues in dispute. An expert may begin by identifying the relevant provisions of the SPA and the accounting framework referred to in those provisions. The financial statements and supporting records can then be considered against that framework.

Reviewing the Relevant SPA Provisions

The SPA may contain several provisions that are relevant to an accounting warranty.

These may include:

  • The warranty itself
  • Definitions of accounting terms
  • References to applicable accounting standards
  • References to prior-period accounts
  • Accounting policy provisions
  • Disclosure provisions
  • Specific treatment agreed for particular items

The expert's financial analysis needs to be based on the relevant contractual framework and the questions within the expert's area of expertise.

Identifying the Applicable Accounting Policies

The next step may involve identifying which accounting policies apply to the financial statements under consideration.

Where the SPA refers to consistency with prior accounts, the relevant reference accounts may also need to be reviewed.

The objective is not simply to identify a theoretically available accounting treatment. It is to establish the accounting basis that is relevant to the particular warranty and transaction documents.

Reviewing the Treatment Adopted

The expert may then examine how individual items were treated in the financial statements.

Depending on the dispute, this could include matters such as:

  • Revenue recognition
  • Provisions
  • Accruals
  • Inventory
  • Receivables
  • Leases
  • Deferred revenue
  • Tax provisions
  • Contingent liabilities
  • Capital expenditure
  • Debt and other financial obligations

The appropriate areas will depend on the allegations made and the wording of the relevant warranty.

Comparing the Adopted Treatment With the Agreed Basis

A central part of the financial analysis may be comparing the treatment actually adopted with the treatment required by the applicable accounting basis.

This comparison can involve several stages.

Establish the Relevant Requirement

The expert may first identify the accounting requirement or contractual provision applicable to the disputed item.

Examine the Supporting Evidence

The underlying accounting records and other relevant documentation may then be reviewed to understand how the item arose and how it was treated.

Assess the Treatment Adopted

The financial statements and relevant accounting schedules can be considered to establish the treatment that was actually applied.

Consider Any Difference

If the adopted treatment differs from the treatment required by the applicable basis, the nature and financial effect of that difference may then need to be assessed.

A difference does not automatically establish a breach of warranty. The conclusion may depend on the precise wording of the warranty, the applicable accounting requirements and the evidence available.

Consistency With Previous Accounting Policies

Consistency can be an important issue where an SPA refers to the accounting policies used in previous periods.

A change in accounting treatment may require examination of:

  • The policy applied in the earlier accounts
  • The policy applied in the relevant accounts
  • The reason for any change
  • Whether the change was permitted under the applicable accounting framework
  • Whether the SPA contains requirements concerning consistency
  • Whether the change was appropriately disclosed

A change in accounting treatment is not necessarily improper simply because the treatment differs from a previous period. The relevant accounting standards, policies and contractual provisions may need to be considered.

The Role of Supporting Accounting Records

Financial statements are prepared from underlying accounting records. Those records may therefore be relevant when assessing how a particular figure was calculated.

Depending on the issue, supporting evidence may include:

  • General ledger entries
  • Journals
  • Invoices
  • Contracts
  • Bank records
  • Debtor and creditor schedules
  • Fixed asset registers
  • Payroll information
  • Tax records
  • Accounting reconciliations

The appropriate evidence will depend on the disputed item.

Reviewing underlying records may help explain how a reported figure was derived and whether the treatment adopted can be reconciled with the relevant accounting basis.

Examples of Accounting Issues That May Require Analysis

The precise issues will vary between transactions, but certain areas can require detailed accounting analysis.

Revenue Recognition

A dispute may concern the period in which revenue was recognised or whether particular revenue transactions were recorded in accordance with the applicable accounting requirements.

The relevant contracts, transaction dates, performance obligations and accounting policies may need to be examined.

Provisions

Questions may arise about whether a provision was required, how it was calculated or whether the amount recognised was consistent with the applicable accounting framework.

The underlying circumstances and evidence available at the relevant reporting date may be important.

Leases

Where lease accounting is relevant, the expert may need to consider the applicable accounting requirements and how lease arrangements were reflected in the financial statements.

Receivables and Bad Debts

The treatment of receivables may require analysis of outstanding balances, recoverability and any provisions or expected credit losses relevant under the applicable accounting framework.

Deferred Revenue

The timing and treatment of revenue received before the relevant accounting period may require examination where it affects the reported financial position or results.

These examples do not establish that a particular accounting treatment is correct or incorrect in any individual transaction. The applicable accounting framework, contractual provisions and evidence need to be considered for the matter in question.

Accounting Standards and the SPA Are Not Always the Same Question

One important distinction is between asking whether financial statements comply with an accounting standard and asking whether they comply with the specific accounting basis required by an SPA.

An SPA may incorporate accounting standards but also refer to particular accounting policies, prior-period treatment or transaction-specific definitions.

Accordingly, an expert may need to consider both:

  • The applicable accounting standards
  • The contractual accounting basis specified by the SPA

The precise relationship between these requirements depends on the wording of the transaction documents.

How the Financial Impact May Be Assessed

Where an accounting difference is identified, the financial consequences may need to be quantified.

For example, an adjustment to a provision, revenue figure or liability could affect reported profit, net assets, working capital or another financial measure relevant to the warranty.

The calculation should identify the basis for the adjustment and distinguish the accounting analysis from any subsequent legal assessment of the claim.

The financial effect of an accounting difference does not, by itself, determine whether a buyer has suffered recoverable loss. Questions of breach, causation, recoverability and damages depend on the relevant facts, contractual provisions and applicable legal framework.

What Evidence May Be Useful to an Expert?

The documents required will depend on the scope of the instruction, but an expert may need access to materials such as:

  • The relevant SPA and schedules
  • The warranted financial statements
  • Prior-period accounts
  • Accounting policies
  • General ledger information
  • Supporting accounting schedules
  • Management accounts
  • Relevant contracts
  • Correspondence concerning disputed accounting treatments
  • Financial due diligence materials
  • Calculations prepared by the parties

A complete document set is not necessarily required for every accounting issue. The expert may identify additional information where the available evidence is insufficient to address a particular question.

Questions to Consider When Reviewing an Accounting Warranty Claim

Before an accounting warranty issue is analysed, solicitors may consider:

What Exactly Does the Warranty Say?

The precise wording should be identified rather than relying on a general description of an accounts warranty.

Which Accounting Basis Applies?

The SPA may refer to IFRS, UK GAAP, specific accounting policies or another agreed basis.

Are Reference Accounts Relevant?

If the SPA refers to prior accounts or policies, those documents may need to be reviewed to establish the relevant accounting treatment.

What Treatment Was Actually Adopted?

The financial statements should be considered alongside the underlying accounting records where appropriate.

Is There Evidence Supporting the Alleged Difference?

A claimed accounting discrepancy may need to be supported by relevant financial records and analysis.

What Is the Financial Effect?

Where an accounting difference is established, the resulting financial impact may need to be separately calculated.

When an Accounting Expert Might Be Involved

A financial or forensic accounting expert may be instructed where a warranty dispute involves specialist questions concerning financial statements, accounting policies, accounting standards or the financial effect of an alleged accounting difference.

The scope of the expert's work will depend on the instructions. It may involve reviewing the SPA and financial statements, analysing disputed accounting treatments, examining supporting records and quantifying a financial adjustment.

The expert's role is to provide independent analysis within their area of expertise. The interpretation of the SPA and the ultimate determination of whether a contractual warranty has been breached remain matters for the appropriate legal or adjudicative process.

For information about the wider services relevant to M&A warranty disputes, see Warranty Claim Expert Services.

Conclusion

An accounting warranty claim may require more than a general assessment of whether financial statements comply with accounting standards.

The relevant analysis may involve identifying the accounting basis specified by the SPA, reviewing the applicable accounting policies, examining the treatment adopted and comparing that treatment with the requirements applicable to the transaction.

Where an accounting difference is identified, its financial effect may then need to be assessed separately. The significance of that difference will depend on the wording of the warranty, the transaction documents, the applicable accounting framework and the evidence available.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal, accounting or expert advice. The appropriate analysis will depend on the facts, transaction documents and evidence relevant to the specific case.

Last Reviewed: October 2026

← Back to the blog·Submit enquiry